Best-rated Hotels in Kelleys Island for an Unforgettable Stay

Book your perfect accommodation with our detailed descriptions, travelers’ reviews, and handpicked hotel collections.

Check-in date:
Check-out date:
0 Adults

Adults

0 Children

Children

Apply

Why Book With Us?

Choose from exclusive hotel collections.

We offer thousands of Kelleys Island hotels and accommodations from some of the world's most renowned hotel chains as well as unique gems in the region that you won’t find anywhere else.

Enjoy a seamless booking experience.

After choosing your accommodation, take a minute to complete our quick reservation form and get instant confirmation by email.

Get flexible travel options.

We provide the most flexible cancellation options. Get your deposit back in case of a change of plans and other unforeseen circumstances.

Find a hotel

Hotels by class
4 stars 1
Unrated 3
Accommodation type
Holiday homes 3
Hotel 1
All Kelleys Island hotels
Ohio >
Kelleys Island

Welcome To Kelleys Island

Discover the allure of Kelleys Island - a captivating gem nestled in Lake Erie. Immerse yourself in its breathtaking natural beauty, from lush forests to pristine beaches. Uncover the island's rich history through its charming Victorian architecture and fascinating museums. Embark on outdoor adventures, indulge in delectable local cuisine, and create lifelong memories. Experience the enchantment firsthand - visit Kelleys Island today!

What Our Users Say About Popular Kelleys Island Hotels

Hyatt Regency Cincinnati
9.8

Exceptional

us Sarah 02 January 2022
The room we booked was brand-new and had a comfortable bed as well as a spacious bathroom.
Read more +
Show Less -
Crowne Plaza Columbus North - Worthington By Ihg
9.8

Exceptional

us Jeanne 08 March 2022
I liked every detail about my quite comfortable stay here during 1 night. Outstanding view of park. Cereals, pastries, fruit, butter and eggs were fresh. Not to mention strong wifi!
Read more +
Show Less -
Hyatt Regency Cleveland At The Arcade
9.8

Exceptional

us Evelyn 24 April 2022
A good stay. We liked this hotel and its good staff and location. Nice building and rooms with modern decoration.
Read more +
Show Less -
Put-In-Bay Resort & Conference Center
9.8

Exceptional

us Joshua 24 January 2023
The location of the resort is perfect, with its proximity to a variety of restaurants and shopping options downtown. Additionally, there is a convenient nearby Candy Bar that offers tea and coffee. The rooms are large, impeccably clean, and the queen beds are incredibly comfortable.
Read more +
Show Less -
Sheraton Suites Columbus Worthington
9.8

Exceptional

us Harriet 23 September 2022
The staff was accommodating. I loved the room with 2 queen beds. - the location was pleasant. - the room was clean.
Read more +
Show Less -
Hotel Cleveland Autograph Collection
9.6

Good

us Gerald 23 July 2022
The staff are wonderful. The room was immaculate. The hotel is in a favorable location close to all major downtown attractions. Summary: Hotel Cleveland Autograph Collection is a great property in Downtown Cleveland, right next to a nice mall and downtown area. The staff are lovely, the rooms are spotless, and the hotel is conveniently situated near all downtown attractions.
Read more +
Show Less -
The Westin Cincinnati
9.8

Exceptional

us A. 14 August 2020
Downtown Cincinnati district definitely deserves exploring. We had a room with pool views. Furthermore, WiFi was a great addition. We really enjoyed this hotel.
Read more +
Show Less -
Hilton Cleveland Downtown
9.8

Exceptional

us Earl 27 March 2021
This hotel was fabulous base for exploring Cleveland, greatly enjoyed it. View looking over lake was the reason we booked queen room. Only 5 min walk to downtown. Worth its 4 stars.
Read more +
Show Less -
Sonesta Columbus Downtown
9.8

Exceptional

us Jesse 08 July 2021
Comfortable stay overall. Location was picturesque, and I loved elegant rooms and brilliant staff. Excellent continental breakfast with perfect choices. It was centrally located. The venue provided a bar in the reception;))
Read more +
Show Less -
Graduate By Hilton Cincinnati
9.6

Good

us Leonard 09 July 2022
The staff here is efficient and accommodating, which makes a difference during a stay.
Read more +
Show Less -

Thank you for your feedback

Close